|
HOTEL DEL CORONADO
Click pictures for a
close-up view in a new window...
THE HISTORY
THE PHOTOS
THE INVESTIGATION
TEAM MEMBER SUMMARY
THE HISTORY
The year is 1885. We find ourselves
in San Diego, California. A wild, rough city back in those days. Murders, suicides, and
death seem to be the mainstream of the city. A battle had already taken place when some of
the city leaders decided to move the main portion of the city from Old Town to New Town
San Diego. Water supplies are not plentiful. Trains are not in yet, connecting the more
northern city of Los Angeles with the far southern city of San Diego. But amidst it all
one man has a dream that he is seeing become a reality. The man is E. B. Babcock. His
dream is to build the most luxurious hotel in the west. Mr. Babcock sets out to fulfill
his dream by purchasing, for $110,000, the island of Coronado and North Island. He intends
to build there. To raise money to help pay for the building he will end up selling parcels
of land to private citizens on the islands.
The cost to build this 399 room
hotel is over one million dollars. He has no real labor force, as a result, he draws upon
the immigrants from China who will work for practically nothing. He begins his task. By
1891 the hotel is not only open, as a show place of the west, but visited for the first
time by a U.S. president, Benjamin Harrison. Hotel del Coronado is now a part of the
entire country's history, not merely California's.
Proudly it sits upon the coast of
the clear, beautiful bay of San Diego. A bridge now joining the city to her. A wonderful
place for recreation and relaxation. The Hotel is grand, not merely in structure but also
in the manner of treatment of its guests. It is known for this. It was also known for
being removed from the woes of the city of San Diego. For back in the 1890s there were
many woes. Murders, suicides, gambling houses, drunken brawls, and more plagued the city.
Hotel del Coronado promised a peaceful time, removed from these afflictions of the city.
So when a young woman, aged 24, by the name of Kate Morgan aka Lottie A. Bernard was found
dead on the steps leading to the beach, it was ruled suicide immediately. Yet does a
suicide victim haunt? If so, why would she? Well we will be traveling down south to the
pearl of pacific hotels to visit and try to discover why she haunts and who is actually
haunting.
Rumors, soon after Kate Morgan's
death, flew about the hotel among its staff that the room she had stayed in was haunted.
The year is 1892 and no one is willing to come forth and testify to what they experienced.
Babcock, though he denied any
belief in ghosts, would not rent out the room unless the entire hotel was filled. If the
room was not haunted, why then did he take this action. Even after Ms. Morgan had died,
the room was not rented out for one month. Of course no records indicate as to why.
The story: Kate Morgan traveled
with her husband Thomas under the name of Lottie A. Bernard. Thomas used the name Dr.
M.C.
Anderson. Their design was one of deception. Kate would play Thomas's sister, getting
young men interested in her. When they wished to court her she would tell them they had to
have her brother's approval, Dr. M.C. Anderson. In order to secure his approval they would
soon discover they had to play poker with him, since that was his main past time. Once the
young suitor was fleeced good and proper, Lottie (Kate) would drop him and move on to the
next young suitor. Thus Kate and husband Thomas managed to make a decent enough living
from this scam. They used alias' because of their family names, both coming from wealthy
families who did not wish to be marked by their con game.
Kate Morgan was a 'natural beauty,'
according to the coroner's report and remained beautiful in death as in life. A small,
petite woman of 24 years who soon found herself wanting more than roaming the train ways
and stage-coach paths to earn money. She told Thomas she wanted a house and a family to go
with it. Thomas was not amenable to such a suggestion but finally gave into her desires
and bought a house in Los Angeles. He then would go out on the road, looking for high
stake poker games, to earn a living.
When he found no money in this,
Kate would work as a housekeeper in Los Angeles, under another alias, to earn the money
necessary for them to live. Thomas started traveling more and more and finally Kate joined
him back on circuit. But when she discovered she was pregnant she remained behind. Thomas
made a tour of the west, from Iowa back to Los Angeles, picking up his wife in route on
his way to San Diego. It on the train ride from L.A. to S.D. that he learned of her
pregnancy. They quarreled, he left the train in Orange, CA and Kate went on to stay at the
Hotel del Coronado.
While she was there, she must have
taken a huge amount of quinine, used to abort a child back in those days, for she suffered
all the symptoms of quinine poisoning. The large bottle of quinine was found in her room
after her death.
Reports state that she went into
San Diego, across the bay by the Coronado Ferry, purchased a .44 caliber pistol and some
shells. She also went to at least one hotel to inquire about the registration of Dr.
M.C.
Anderson. The next morning she was found dead on the steps leading to the beach just off
the veranda of the Hotel del Coronado. A small bullet wound to her right temple, no exit
wound, blood on her hand and the gun, which lay two steps
above her hand. Did she kill
herself? Is she the one who haunts? If so, why does she do so?
THE INVESTIGATION
Snap! Then the grind of the motor
pushes the single picture out of the Polaroid camera. Snap! again, and again the motor
pushes another picture out of the camera. And then we wait. Hoping above all that these
pictures will develop right before our very eyes to reveal something, anything, to confirm
the stories told of this room. The room, 3312, at the Hotel del Coronado.
We made a
trip down south to investigate the "haunted" room of the Hotel del
Coronado. We were greeted with a smile by the gentlemen of the valet parking as well as
the reservation clerk who checked us into our room. We were treated with the utmost
courtesy. The front lobby reeks with the history of this grand hotel. The wood is, without
mistake, of the finest quality and the original material placed in the hotel when it was
built back in 1889 to 1891. The old elevator reminds one of the Gay 90s period. The
building creeks and lists slightly, from the wear and tear over the years, but still
commands a stately presence on Coronado island. Its high, catwalk like dome, reaches out
towards the night sky, lit by the lights that cascade down its roof. Standing clearly as a
beacon to all those within several miles of the island. The hotel is magnificent, perhaps
not as much as it was back in the 1890s but almost equally as much.
We make a call to the reservations
office, asking to speak with Susan. Susan is the only the reason we are here and were
guaranteed this room. This room, the most requested room of the hotel, is kept rather busy
by guests seeking a paranormal experience. Susan is invited to the room. We are delighted
to meet with her. She is friendly, open, quite charming and extremely helpful.
Susan tells us of her experience in
this haunted room. It seems, one other time when she was helpful to others checking into
this room, she was invited to come and meet the people. When she arrived they chatted
briefly about different things, including the ghost in the room. Suddenly the lady Susan
was visiting realized her large emerald ring was missing. Susan remembered seeing the ring
on the lady's finger when she shook hands with her. The lady, gentleman, and Susan spent
several minutes searching the room for the ring; it was not to be found. Susan called
security for assistance. They also joined in on the search, still the ring was not to be
found. Security filed a report, then left. Susan felt horrible. She was convinced the
guests would think she had taken the ring somehow. The lady excused herself and went into
the bathroom, coming back out within a couple of seconds. There in her hand was the ring.
She had found it on the sink. She had not been in the bathroom since Susan arrived and
since Susan had seen the ring on her finger, the only explanation was Kate, the ghost of
room 3312, had borrowed the ring for a short time.
Susan, greatly relieved, left,
telling the guests to please call her if they needed anything. She told them to just dial
5. She left the room and returned to the reservations office. Shortly after getting back
to her office, she remembered the number for reservations had just been changed and 5 was
no longer for reservations but for the front desk. Before she had the chance to call the
guests to tell them of the new number the phone rang. It was the guests. Susan asked how
they reached her, the woman said, why we dialed 5 just as you said to.
This is just one story. There are
so many, many more.
One of our
visitors wrote and asked if we ever viewed the videotapes from our
investigation at the Hotel Del Coronado. We did in fact view the
tapes, but with all the things happening in our lives no one on the
team took the time to write an updated report.
We placed three different video cameras in the room. We also placed
three different tape recorders in the room. In the late afternoon of
our first day we turned all the equipment on, verified it was
working properly then left the room to go to dinner. The videotape
showed us leaving the room. THE MOMENT the door closed,
the videotapes all went fuzzy then to snow. The recording equipment
picked up our conversation as we were preparing to leave but once
the door was closed the tape was filled by an inconsistent thumping
noise that was recorded and a static-y sound. The thumping sound on
the tape was never identified by any of us. The truly
interesting part is that when we returned all the static and snow
stopped and things went back to normal.
We continued to run the video cameras throughout our entire stay but
nothing truly unusual could be seen. There were some minor orbs of
light but nothing highly unusual.
Our best photographic material came from two different Polaroid cameras, a Nikon camera and a Canon AE1, which had infrared film loaded in it. Many of these photos are on our site already.
Which brings me to the point of suggestion for those who wish to investigate haunted places. Our experience has been that Polaroid cameras seem to produce the best results. The Nikon camera used was fully automatic, this type of camera has some major drawbacks in that in the darkness the flash will always flash and this can cause an unrealistic result. The Canon AE1 is a manual camera and as a result infrared film can be used in it without problems. Allowing us to take photos in nearly total darkness and yet still producing results. We have, since this investigation, added to our collection of cameras, a Sony Digital, a Minolta fully automatic 35mm, plus an Olympus Digital 720. However we still find the Polaroid to yield the best results. The only requirements for the Polaroid is to make certain it has been cleaned by a professional to insure all parts are operating properly and to have several film packs to use during the investigation.
ONE
TEAM MEMBER'S OPINION & SUMMARY:
I need to start off by telling you
that I personally do NOT believe for 1 split-second
that Kate Morgan committed suicide - based on the research we did -
it would have been almost if not completely impossible. The
unfortunate thing was that because of it's ties/attachment to wealth
and political persons, the hotel could simply not afford to
be linked with a murder and I believe some possibly
well-intentioned people opted to cover it up as a suicide.
In the room itself I got some VERY
interesting photos but must admit that psychic-wise I really did not
feel any kind of overwhelming presence...Had we not had the camera,
video and audio experiences we did, I might not have even believed
the room was haunted. I am usually very "sensitive" so this
was kind of surprising for me...
Besides staying at the Coronado, we
spent a LOT of time researching things, at the college in San Diego
where old hotel registers were kept, at gun dealers and numerous
other places. Unfortunately many records from that time frame
were destroyed in the big fire that occurred in San Diego around
that time frame.
Let me tell you why I don't believe
it was a suicide; here are the facts as we discovered them:
- Kate Morgan stood under 5 feet
tall and weighed 90 some-odd pounds.
- At the time of her death she was
sick with quinine poisoning (as records attest to) from trying to
abort her unborn child.
- Reportedly when she went to
purchase the gun she was too weak to even get on and off the ferry
or cable car without being lifted.
- The night of her death was the
first big storm of the season - winds were very strong and
the side of the Coronado where her body was found lies right on
the beachfront.
- We went to a gun dealer to
determine facts about the American Bulldog gun. While he did
not have any of those (naturally) he gave us a gun to handle that
was approximately the same size and weight (actually a little
smaller...) Now, I am not a small person and it was
heavy to me - and I would have had a
hard time firing it.
- The gun was actually found 2
steps ABOVE Kate Morgan's lifeless body.
- There was no exit wound from a
point-blank shot to the head and there was absolutely no gun
powder on her hands or around the entrance wound. (mind you,
the "bullets" were actually round pellets almost but there still
should have been residue somewhere...)
- Kate was completely dressed in
eveningwear and a sealskin coat, and she carried her handbag.
But her clothing (even her coat) was not soaking wet
in spite of the torrential rain that night.
- After her death, the hotel
decided to "remodel" her room and shut it off from access for a
month. This room was one of the most - if not THE most
popular room they reserved regularly...
THE QUESTIONS
ARISE:
- HOW could a woman of her
size, being so weak she could not step down from or up to a cable
car without someone lifting her, in the high winds of the first
storm, standing on the beachside of the hotel, have held that
heavy gun to her own head and fired it?
- AND...even if she had, at
close range like that why was there no exit-wound?
- AND...why was her
clothing not wet from the storm?
- AND...why would she dress
fully in eveningwear and take her handbag down with her to shoot
herself in the middle of the night?
- AND...why was the gun
found 2 steps ABOVE her? Had she shot
herself the falling with her arm pointed downwards should have
thrown the heavy gun down -- if you believe in gravity anyway.
- Finally...why was the
room she stayed in effectively shut down for 30 days after her
death for "remodeling"? Why that room? What at that time?
There are far too many unanswered
questions - too many pieces that do not add up... I believe
Kate was actually murdered - in her room
and carried outside through the underground catacombs to avoid a
scandal. In fact, we did a re-enactment of how it could have
been done - sneaking through the catacombs late that night and it
would have been VERY easy for a body to have been moved without
others noticing.
Who killed her? Obviously I
cannot say for sure. My own personal belief is that it was her
husband. I think she bought the gun to threaten him, found him
at another hotel (probably with another young woman) and made a
scene. I suspect he told her he would come to the Coronado and they
would work things out. When he got there, he killed her with
the gun she bought. Then he, or someone attempting to cover up
the murder, simply dragged her body to the steps to make it appear
like a suicide. In that day and age it would not have been
questioned the way it would be today. But looking at the facts
made ME sure it was not a suicide.
|